To snack or not to snack that is the question
Back

To snack or not to snack that is the question

By: Cecilia Harris
October 24, 2018
Although our grandparents and great-grandparents typically ate three meals a day, today we eat five times a day, on average. And although it’s often claimed that eating more often can help you control your weight, it doesn’t seem to be working out that way. 

Snacking is optional

Here in the UK it’s gotten to the point that we now eat pretty much constantly—in the car, at our desks, at the cinema, and while we shop. I’ve even seen people eat during their workouts at the gym!

Snacking has become so institutionalised that most “nutritious” meal plans now include three meals and at least two snacks. In fact, many people now view snacking as a nutritional necessity.

Countless diet gurus and personal trainers insist that you must eat every two to three hours to keep your metabolism revved up. However, just because you’ve read or heard this a few thousand times doesn’t make it true.

Not only will your metabolism not slow down if you go more than three hours without food, but there may actually be some benefits to going longer between meals.

The popular notion that eating every few hours will keep your metabolism revved up is based on a couple of different misunderstandings about how metabolism works.

The first has to do with the so-called starvation mode. If you go too long without eating, your body adjusts its metabolism to conserve energy and burn fewer calories, just in case the food shortage continues. Going into “starvation mode” is a survival strategy.

During a famine you’d need to live on your stored fat and down- regulating your metabolism is a way to make those fat stores go a bit farther. It’s similar to the way your laptop adjusts its energy usage when it’s running on batteries, such as by making the screen a little dimmer.

When food is plentiful again, your metabolism goes back to normal, just the way your screen gets brighter when you plug your laptop back in. If there actually were a famine, you’d be glad that your body is designed this way. But if you’re trying to maintain your weight or lose a few pounds, the last thing you want is increased fuel efficiency.

You want to be burning through stored fat like a Ferrari burns through a tank of petrol. And supposedly, if you reassure your body that there is no shortage of food by eating every few hours, it will oblige you by continuing to burn calories with reckless metabolic abandon.

The argument makes sense, except for one small thing. Your body doesn’t go into starvation mode if you go three hours without food. It takes about three days of fasting or serious caloric restriction for your body to respond with any sort of metabolic adjustment.

Rest assured that going four or even twelve hours between meals will have virtually no effect on your metabolism.

In fact, going longer between meals can have some very beneficial effects on your blood sugar and other aspects of your health. It takes about three hours for your body to finish digesting a meal. If you eat every two or three hours, as everyone insists you should, your body will constantly be in what nutritionists call the “fed state.” That simply means that you are always in the process of digesting food.

If, on the other hand, you don’t eat again, you’ll go into somthing we call the “postabsorptive state” after about three hours. Several interesting things happen in the postabsorptive state, which continues for another twelve to eighteen hours if you don’t eat again.

First, you begin tapping into your body’s stored energy reserves to run your engine. Your hormone levels adjust to shift your body out of fat-storage mode and into fat-burning mode. Hanging out in the postabsorptive state also reduces free-radical damage and inflammation, increases the production of antiaging hormones, and promotes tissue repair. And, of course, your metabolic rate remains unchanged.

The biggest problem you are likely to experience if you go a bit longer between meals is feeling hungry, and this is not as big a problem as many of us have led ourselves to believe.

When you are used to always being in the fed state, you tend to panic the minute you notice that your stomach is empty. In fact, feeling hungry is not a medical emergency.

Often, if you simply wait ten minutes, the feeling will go away. Sometimes simply having a cup of tea or a glass of water does the trick. Allowing your stomach to be empty for an hour or two is really not that uncomfortable if you let yourself get used to the sensation. It’s also the perfect time to exercise.

Exercising two or three hours after you eat will allow you to get the most out of your workout and, as a bonus, usually makes hunger pangs go away.

Don’t misunderstand what I’m saying here: I’m not advising you to stop eating or to starve yourself. But as long as you are eating the appropriate amount of food each day, it’s okay to feel hungry between meals.

I’m not against snacking, as I’m an enthusiastic snacker myself. But contrary to what you may have been led to believe, snacking is definitely optional. And when you choose to snack, you want to be sure you’re doing it well.

Some people find that eating five or six times a day instead of the traditional three square meals works better for them. For example, you may make better dietary choices if you don’t let yourself get as hungry between meals. If that helps you maintain a healthy diet, it’s a valid option.

Just don’t let the metabolism myth seduce you into thinking that eating more frequently allows you to eat more. If you’re gaining weight when you don’t mean to (or not losing when you’re trying to), it’s a sign that you need to cut back on the size of your meals or the number of your snacks (or both).

My favourite healthy snacks :

Tesco's finest spiced beetroot

Raw carrots

Raw celery sticks

Raw peppers

Almonds

Other nuts and seeds

Cucumber sticks

Apple

Hard boiled egg

Avocado

Protein balls (home made are best)

Herbal teas

Although I think it’s always preferable to snack on real food, there are all kinds of energy and meal replacement bars designed to offer a convenient solution to your on-the-go nutrition needs. They don’t need refrigeration, preparation, or even utensils. In a pinch, they will keep you going. But it’s important to match the bar to the situation.

For example, if it’s 3pm and you’re sitting at your desk feeling a little groggy, it might seem like an energy bar would be the perfect solution. But unless your job involves heavy physical work, that’s not really the kind of energy you’re looking for.

More likely, you could use a break, a walk, a stretch, some fresh air, a cup of tea. Any of these will be more energising than a concentrated dose of carbohydrates.

My tips to stop the snacks attacks :

 

1- Eat bigger breakfast. If you’re trying to make it five hours until lunch time, you’d want to eat more like 400 or 500 calories for breakfast. It also helps if your 3 meals a day are balanced and nutritious, containing protein, healthy fats, and slow-burning carbohydrates, such as those you get from vegetables, whole grains, and beans.

2- When you feel hungry between meals wait at least ten minutes if it doesn't go away have a glass of water or a tasty herbal tea.

3- Take your time. When you are snacking let's say on nuts. Eat 1 nut at a time make it last longer and slow the whole process down.

4- Snack on real food not snack foods. Make your own and plan your meals in advance. Planning is key!

 

 

👉🏽 For more advice and tips, check out our other blog on snacking or get started today on our 10 day free trial for more nutritional advice 👈🏽

Happy Snacking 😜

Love

Cecilia xx

Cecilia is the co-founder of Results with Lucy and face of Results with Cecilia.

Sign up to our newsletters

Related Articles
Music as A Motivator
Music as A Motivator
February 11, 2019
I don’t know about you, but I just LOVE working out with some of my
By: Lucy Mecklenburgh
To Retreat, Or Not To Retreat: That Is The Question!
To Retreat, Or Not To Retreat: That Is The Question!
February 05, 2019
👉🏽 If you can hear a Results with Lucy retreat calling YOUR name, click here
By: Lucy Mecklenburgh
Your Results with Lucy Body Confidence Masterclass
Your Results with Lucy Body Confidence Masterclass
March 11, 2019
For a lot of women who join one of our Results with Lucy memberships, it
By: Lucy Mecklenburgh
10 Ways to Sneak in Exercise into YOUR Daily Routine with Results with Lucy
10 Ways to Sneak in Exercise into YOUR Daily Routine with Results with Lucy
March 04, 2019
When it comes to health and fitness, every choice you make determines how quickly you
By: Lucy Mecklenburgh
#rwlreinventforlent2019 Our RwL Alternative Lent Ideas!
#rwlreinventforlent2019 Our RwL Alternative Lent Ideas!
March 05, 2019
After all of the pancakes have been enjoyed on Shrove Tuesday (Pancake Day) 🥞, Lent
By: Lucy Mecklenburgh
Find your Fitness Time - Working Out to Fit Your Lifestyle with Results with Lucy!
Find your Fitness Time - Working Out to Fit Your Lifestyle with Results with Lucy!
March 04, 2019
Hi Dolls, I’m Jo and I am one of the Results with Lucy Ambassadors and
Pancake Day 2019
Pancake Day 2019
February 28, 2019
🥞 For a tasty treat or a lazy morning breakfast, we're here to give you
By: Lucy Mecklenburgh
5 Ways To Boost Your Energy Levels
5 Ways To Boost Your Energy Levels
February 27, 2019
Do you often feel tired and wish you could be more energetic and able to
By: Cecilia Harris
The Ultimate Guide To Help You Overcome Your Plateau
The Ultimate Guide To Help You Overcome Your Plateau
February 26, 2019
It’s fairly common that most people on a weight loss journey will hit a plateau.
By: Lucy Mecklenburgh
REAL RESULTS - KATIE BISHOP
REAL RESULTS - KATIE BISHOP
February 22, 2019
  Name: Katie Bishop Age: 26 Length of current progress: 9 months Weight lost: 3
Health & Fitness - Star PT Secrets
Health & Fitness - Star PT Secrets
February 22, 2019
January 2019 - 
With Self Love: Body Positivity
With Self Love: Body Positivity
February 08, 2019
Body positivity has been a topic of much discussion over the last year. Why do
By: Lucy Mecklenburgh
#caseysdiary - My Second Trimester Of Pregnancy
#caseysdiary - My Second Trimester Of Pregnancy
February 14, 2019
Missed Casey's First Trimester blog? Click here to catch up!   GLOWING! ✨One word I was
Couples that train together!
Couples that train together!
February 13, 2019
Hey! My names Bek and I’m one of the RWL Ambassadors, I have been with
A FREE 3-course meal for 2 people this Valentines Day
A FREE 3-course meal for 2 people this Valentines Day
February 12, 2019
If you’re looking for a healthy way to satisfy your sweet tooth this Valentines Day
By: Lucy Mecklenburgh
How To Build Support Networks
How To Build Support Networks
February 06, 2019
How To Build Support Network We've all been there, starting out on our new health
Mental Health and Me: How I Use Results with Lucy to Promote Positive Mental Health
Mental Health and Me: How I Use Results with Lucy to Promote Positive Mental Health
February 06, 2019
Results with Lucy Ambassador, Jayme, tells us all about how she uses Results with Lucy
How To Eat Healthy For Less with Results with Lucy
How To Eat Healthy For Less with Results with Lucy
January 31, 2019
It is 100% possible to eat healthy for less whilst following Results With Lucy. If
#selfcaresunday : Why Self Care is SO Important
#selfcaresunday : Why Self Care is SO Important
February 08, 2019
Self-care is so important to us all and you can show yourself some self-care in
By: Lucy Mecklenburgh
#foreverfitafterforty: The Changing Shape of Forty-Something
#foreverfitafterforty: The Changing Shape of Forty-Something
January 24, 2019
Meet Results with Lucy’s Head PT, Cecilia and one of our RwL Ambassadors, Christine:  
By: Cecilia Harris
The Feel Good Factor: What Makes You Feel Good?
The Feel Good Factor: What Makes You Feel Good?
January 30, 2019
With the fast-paced nature of 21st century life we can often find ourselves not affording
By: Lucy Mecklenburgh
Failure vs. Success: Why failing is part of your success!
Failure vs. Success: Why failing is part of your success!
January 20, 2019
How often have you though to yourself; “I didn’t stick to my diet this week,
By: Cecilia Harris
Reframing Your Mindset Around Food
Reframing Your Mindset Around Food
January 14, 2019
We’ve all been there! Setting ourselves an inspiring goal and committing to a new healthy lifestyle.
How to Stop the Curse of the New Year’s Resolution!
How to Stop the Curse of the New Year’s Resolution!
January 11, 2019
It is said that 60% of people who start a resolution to become healthier stop
By: Lucy Mecklenburgh
Why did your last diet fail? Find the PERFECT diet for you today!
Why did your last diet fail? Find the PERFECT diet for you today!
January 10, 2019
Why did your last diet fail?... It's because you didn't KISS enough 😱 Keep it Simple Sister
By: Cecilia Harris
Sports Bras For Bigger Busts
Sports Bras For Bigger Busts
January 15, 2019
Results with Lucy is all about getting fit and feeling good in the comfort of
6 top tips to getting back on track
6 top tips to getting back on track
July 30, 2018
Lots of people find it difficult to maintain any kind of structure over Christmas which can
By: Lucy Mecklenburgh
#caseysdiary - My First Trimester of Pregnancy
#caseysdiary - My First Trimester of Pregnancy
January 10, 2019
"PREGNANT! One word I thought I might not get to hear again, and here I
Vitality in Veganuary
Vitality in Veganuary
January 11, 2019
It’s the time of year where New Year’s resolutions are in abundance and the Veganuary
What Equipment Should I Buy? Your Guide to Getting Started with Your Workouts
What Equipment Should I Buy? Your Guide to Getting Started with Your Workouts
January 05, 2019
When starting out on a new workout program, it can be a little overwhelming 🤯
By: Lucy Mecklenburgh
Your Guide to Motivation and Creating Healthy Habits
Your Guide to Motivation and Creating Healthy Habits
December 28, 2018
For many, a New Year brings silent promises of change, feelings of hope and a
By: Lucy Mecklenburgh
Your January Guide to Starting Your Health & Wellness Journey
Your January Guide to Starting Your Health & Wellness Journey
December 21, 2018
It’s that time of year where we indulge on all of the treats, drink a
By: Lucy Mecklenburgh
Cold and Flu remedies that actually work
Cold and Flu remedies that actually work
December 18, 2018
Are you sick and tired of those cold and flu remedies that just don’t cut
6 moves to thinner thighs
6 moves to thinner thighs
November 19, 2018
Bikini season may be well and truly over... ❄️😰   ... but summer bodies can
By: Lucy Mecklenburgh
To snack or not to snack that is the question
To snack or not to snack that is the question
October 24, 2018
Although our grandparents and great-grandparents typically ate three meals a day, today we eat five
By: Cecilia Harris
Why it's NEVER too late to get started
Why it's NEVER too late to get started
October 23, 2018
Have you ever decided to make a healthy lifestyle change but quickly given up or
By: Lucy Mecklenburgh
My Ultimate FAQ's
My Ultimate FAQ's
October 19, 2018
I get asked soooooo many of the same questions every single day about fitness, health
By: Lucy Mecklenburgh
How to begin your self love journey
How to begin your self love journey
October 18, 2018
Why are we drawn to these magazines that do nothing but demean us? I strongly
By: Cecilia Harris
Winter weight loss & motivation tips ❄️👍🏼
Winter weight loss & motivation tips ❄️👍🏼
October 17, 2018
Despite your best intentions... you know that over the festive period and upcoming Winter months,
By: Lucy Mecklenburgh
The best diet which will work for YOU
The best diet which will work for YOU
September 25, 2018
The Best Diet That Works for You: The One You Can Stick To All the
By: Cecilia Harris
Does at home, online personal training really work?
Does at home, online personal training really work?
September 25, 2018
This is a common question we get asked at Results with Lucy. You only have
By: Lucy Mecklenburgh
11 exercises you can do at your desk
11 exercises you can do at your desk
September 11, 2018
How many hours do YOU spend sitting at your desk every single day? How long
By: Cecilia Harris
Overcoming social anxiety
Overcoming social anxiety
September 12, 2018
Have you ever felt Self-Conscious in social situations? Have you ever worried excessively about going
Am I getting enough protein? 🤔
Am I getting enough protein? 🤔
September 07, 2018
We get sooo many questions about protein here at RwL HQ, so we thought we'd quickly
By: Lucy Mecklenburgh
Why it's not too late to STILL get fit this year
Why it's not too late to STILL get fit this year
August 22, 2018
Have you ever decided to make a healthy lifestyle change but quickly given up or
By: Lucy Mecklenburgh
Top tips on toning up
Top tips on toning up
August 08, 2018
It's quite simple on how to lose weight & tone up which is why we
By: Cecilia Harris
GET LEAN: What my low-carb diet results actually looked like
GET LEAN: What my low-carb diet results actually looked like
August 02, 2018
I've tried my fair share of weird weight-loss strategies in my life like most people.
By: Cecilia Harris
How to get the most out of Results with Lucy
How to get the most out of Results with Lucy
July 27, 2018
Signed up to Results with Lucy recently, or looking to, and not sure really where
By: Lucy Mecklenburgh
How to avoid temptations and say no!
How to avoid temptations and say no!
July 27, 2018
Just say NO! If only it was that simple... well actually, it is!😮 We are
By: Lucy Mecklenburgh
How to reduce bloating on holiday
How to reduce bloating on holiday
July 25, 2018
Let's face it... at some point whilst you're away, you're most probably going to feel bloated from the
By: Lucy Mecklenburgh
0 Comments

All blog comments are checked prior to publishing